top of page
ORDER ONLINE
We're not accepting online orders yet. Please contact us to complete the order.
Pickup, ASAP (in 15 minutes)
APPETIZERS
To Share or Not to Share
Tender Seasoned Sirloin Steak, Diced and Fried13.00 USD
House Blended Spinach & Artichoke Dip, Paired with House Made Naan Tandoori13.00 USD
Golden Fried Onion Rings11.00 USD
Fried, Wisconsin White Battered Curds, Served with Ranch.12.00 USD
Duck, bacon, sweet corn, and cream cheese wontons.14.00 USD
Double garlic, double cheese bread with warm pub red sauce13.00 USD
Double order of fries, white cheddar curds, gravy, bacon and sausage.12.00 USD
Infused cream cheese blend, buffalo sauce, ranch dressing, pulled chicken and flatbread.13.00 USD
SOUPS & SALADS
Soups
Dempsey's Northern Version of Jambalaya.... andouille sausage, infused rice, chili beans, grilled chicken & our blend of spices. (This soup is spicy!)4.00 USD
Dempsey's Northern Version of Jambalaya.... andouille sausage, infused rice, chili beans, grilled chicken & our blend of spices. (This soup is spicy!)6.00 USD
Hand crafted daily by our crew.4.00 USD
Hand crafted daily by our crew.6.00 USD
Salads
Good ol' fashioned fresh cut greens, spinach & spring mix.
Pulled chicken, avocados, cherry tomatoes, onions, bleu cheese crumbles, broccoli florets, mushrooms, egg garnish & dressing of your choice.13.50 USD
Grilled or Fried Chicken, Chopped Pickles, Grape Tomatoes, Bleu Cheese, Smoked Bacon, Served with Buffalo Sauce & Ranch Dressing.15.00 USD
Battered shrimp (tossed in mae poy sauce), feta cheese, tomatoes, onions, mandarin oranges, and bacon.15.00 USD
Capicola, pepperoni, romaine lettuce, pepperoncini peppers, tomatoes, green olives, red onions, egg and mozzarella cheese.15.00 USD
BASKETS
All Baskets Served with Fries & Coleslaw
Battered White Meat Chicken Tenders Served with Coleslaw and Fries. Don't forget to ask for Dip!13.50 USD
Battered Salt & Vinegar Cod served with Coleslaw and Thick Cut Fries. Served with House Tartar.13.50 USD
1/2 lb. Fried Chislic Served with Seasoned Fries and Coleslaw.14.00 USD
Served with coleslaw and seasoned fries.14.00 USD
GRINDS & SANDWICHES
Served with Your Choice of Side
Most breads are made in-house. Some of our breads contain nuts. If you have any specific allergy, please notify your server. All burgers are 1/2 lb. fresh cut.
Roast Beef, Havarti Cheese, Toasted Hoagie & Au Jus.14.50 USD
Balsamic onion jam, white cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon + LTO on a kaiser roll.15.00 USD
Garlic sauerkraut, thin sliced corned beef, havarti cheese, 1000 island on house made rye.14.50 USD
Alabama White BBQ Sauce, fried chicken filet, applewood smoked bacon, fresh jalapenos, french fried onions, lettuce and tomato on a kaiser roll. 14.50 USD
Sauteed garlic mushrooms, melted white cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato on a kaiser roll.15.00 USD
Gluten Free Bun + $1.
Comes with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion and Pickles. Additional Toppings for $.50 Each.12.00 USD
Cranberry brie cheese spread, smoked turkey breast, double bacon, havarti and cheddar on house made rye.0.00 USD
Calzones
The Starlights
Pesto Base, Whipped Ricotta, Fresh Mozzarella, Grilled Chicken, Tomatoes, Onions, Spinach and Balsamic Drizzle.12.00 USD
Alabama White BBQ sauce, whipped ricotta, whole milk mozzarella, pepperoni, beef, bacon and pepperoncini peppers.12.00 USD
Vegan mozzarella, pesto base, jalapenos, onions, mushrooms, plant-Based Pepperoni. 12.00 USD
PIZZAS
Signature Pizzas
National & International Award Winning Pizzas, curated by United States Pizza Team Member Sean Dempsey. Something for everyone's taste, cooked in our MB60 double deck brick oven, all 24-48 hour cold rise method. All pizzas are served with Baccio Whole Milk Mozzarella (with a kiss of buffalo milk) unless noted with fresh mozzarella instead. 12" Specialty (Original or Pan) $15 | 15" Specialty (Original) $18.5 | $10.5 | 15" Take and Bake (Specialty) $14 | 10.5" Cauliflower GF Crust $13.50 | 8" Personal Pizza $9.00 Don't Forget to Ask About Our Pizza of The Week
Dempsey's House Red Sauce, Char N Cup Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Green peppers, Black Olives, Baby Bella Mushrooms. NY Style/Calzone0.00 USD
House-made ranch, pulled chicken, smoked bacon, and cherry tomatoes.0.00 USD
Dempsey's House Red Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, Tomatoes, EVOO Drizzle.0.00 USD
Alfredo Base, Chicken, Spinach Leaves, Smoked bacon. NY Style/Calzone.0.00 USD
Capicola, Prosciutto di Parma, Fresh Pineapple, Jalapenos, Bacon, Gouda Cheese, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle. NY Style/Calzone.0.00 USD
1000 Island Base, Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Pickles, Balsamic Drizzle. NY Style/Calzone.0.00 USD
Pizza of the Week. Changes every week!0.00 USD
Alabama White BBQ Sauce, chicken, bacon, caramelized onions, jalapenos and cheddar jack cheese.0.00 USD
Double pepperoni, minced garlic, hot honey drizzle and fresh basil.0.00 USD
Pub red sauce, pepperoni, capicola, sausage, ground beef and bacon.0.00 USD
Pesto base, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, onions, spinach leaves, chicken, post-bake balsamic drizzle.0.00 USD
Make Your Own Masterpiece
Build the Pizza You Want, the Way You Want.
14.00 USD
15.00 USD
10.00 USD
13.50 USD
Char N Cup Pepperoni
Italian Sausage
Prosciutto di Parma
Capicola
Ground Beef
Chicken
Smoked Bacon1.00 USD
Fresh Cut Pineapple
Minced Garlic
Baby Bella Mushrooms
Red Onions
Black/Green Olives
Cherry/Roma Tomatoes
Green Peppers
Peppadews
Fresh Jalapenos
Pickles
Fresh Basil
Baby Spinach
Artichoke Hearts
Feta Cheese
Extra Cheese1.00 USD
Chicago Tavern Thin Specialties
Pepperoni, double sausage, red onions, minced garlic and hot oil drizzle17.00 USD
Alfredo base, roast beef, green peppers, onions, mushrooms and giariniera17.00 USD
Alabama whit bbq sauce, whole milk mozzarella, capicola, bacon, burger, pepperoncini peppers and peppadews17.00 USD
Pesto, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, minced garlic and black Olives17.00 USD
TRADITIONAL FARE
Served with Your Choice of Soup or Side Salad
An Austrian Tradition! Tenderized Breaded Pork Filet, Pan Fried in Butter, Served with Spätzle Dumplings, Braised Red Cabbage & Lemon Wedges.17.00 USD
Grilled Chicken, Cavatappi Noodles, Smoked Bacon, Peas, Alfredo Sauce & Finished with Black Pepper and Fresh Parsley.17.00 USD
Potato and cheese stuffed pierogies, sauteed with onions and bacon. Served with a side of alfredo.16.00 USD
8 oz. sirloin, finished with a Jameson Irish whiskey glaze, and served with choice of side.18.00 USD
Twin Jungers Farm Butchers Sausages, mashed potatoes, sauteed onions and gravy17.00 USD
Tenderized sirloin, breaded and pan fried, served with braised red cabbage, garlic mushrooms, mashed potatoes, gravy and topped with french fried onions18.00 USD
KID'S MENU
For the Young and Young at Heart
Kraft Mac N Cheese5.00 USD
Served with Fries.5.00 USD
5.00 USD
5.00 USD
2.00 USD
SIDES
Teamwork Makes the Dream Work
0.00 USD
Creamy house slaw or a cup of jambalaya/soup of the day.0.00 USD
0.00 USD
3.00 USD
3.00 USD
0.00 USD
2.00 USD
3.00 USD
DESSERTS
We don’t have anything to show at the moment.
bottom of page